Interesting segment on BBC World Service Thursday, covering the issue of Trump’s immigration policies. One of the cities at the forefront of the #resistance is Seattle, and its mayor, Ed Murray.
Ed Murray and Seattle
I’ll be honest I didn’t now much about Murray, prior to listening to this segment. He runs Seattle, and that city really isn’t on my radar, other than the Sounders are a fun soccer club to watch. When the BBC news reader introduced the segment on the podcast, I thought, well, of course Seattle is going to be out there on this subject. The personal angle Murray discussed was important: his husband, Mike Shiosaki, and his family, if he supported the preposterous policies Trump wants to see implemented. Murray’s and Shiosai’s story is fascinating, and they did a StoryCorps piece, discussing it.
The Case Against Trump
Back to the Beeb piece. Ed Murray made two important points on Trump’s crazy-ass ideas. First was how Washington State has the second largest wine industry in the nation, and their overall agriculture production is an important part of the state’s economy. The overwhelming number of farm workers on the west coast are undocumented. That means there are a lot of business owners relying on that labor force. If Trump packs them up and ships them off, there won’t be anybody around to pick the grapes.
The second point was how hollow Trump’s primary threat against cities like Seattle really is. The Beeb correspondent pressed Murray more than once for his response to the threat that Trump would pull federal funding from a “sanctuary city” (or, as Murray prefers, a “welcoming city”). He pointed out that the amount of aid Seattle gets from the feds as been dwindling for decades. If Trump were to cut off what was left Seattle would be able to cope, since the percentage is insignificant.
Calling Bullshit on Trump
The one thing about Murray, he didn’t simply extend Trump an upraised middle finger. He made a solid case for why the policy is not much more than bullshit and rhetoric without relying on bullshit and rhetoric himself. If Seattle can spare Mr. Murray, and his husband doesn’t mind, I do hope the mayor considers moving up to a higher level, politically.